Tuesday, September 12, 2006

Election Disaster in Montgomery

The Montgomery County Board of Elections failed to deliver the cards needed to activate the County's electronic voting machines. As a result, the polls were not able to open on time throughout the County. Some voters were able to cast provisional paper ballots. However, polling places had a limited supply. I was handing out campaign literature at Rollingwood School and they ran out eventually. In any case, few voters showed up for the traditional pre-work rush to the polls at this normally very busy precinct because of news reports of the problem.

It took some time time to get the electronic machines up and running as the cards had to be delivered by hand to each of the County's 238 precincts. The polls are supposed to open at 7AM. Rollingwood didn't get its electronic machines up and running until around 8:20AM. Chevy Chase Elementary didn't get their machines up until at least 15 minutes later.

The problems didn't stop there. The County has now moved to an electronic system for checking in voters when they arrive at the polls. After the election judge checks in the voter, the machine prints out a receipt which the voter must sign and encodes the electronic card which allows the voter then inserts in the voting machine to activate it. Just as the election judge checked me in, the machine crashed. When it restarted, it said that I had already voted even though I had not. Fortunately, it had encoded the card to allow me to vote and I was able to cast a ballot even though it did not print out a receipt. We had to take care of that part manually.

Meanwhile, some voters clearly still find the electronic machines confusing. Two older voters at the booth next to mine accidentally cast their ballot before they had finished voting for all of the offices. I don't know if this is a common problem but I can see how people might accidentally flip past some screens and then hit cast a ballot. The touch pad locates the "next screen" and "cast your ballot" buttons in the same part of the screen. It seems possible to flip past a "page" of the ballot and even to cast your ballot by accident.

If fewer people vote in Montgomery, it could have a big impact on the election. Ben Cardin expects to do well here so fewer voters in Montgomery would likely aid Kweisi Mfume. Doug Gansler, the County's State's Attorney, is running for Attorney General and similarly would like a high turnout in Montgomery in his race against Stuart Simms, a former State's Attorney from Baltimore City.

Within Montgomery, individual local and state legislative candidates could benefit if some polling places got their machines up and running earlier than others as well. There is talk of extending voting around the state. However, many voters who showed up at the polls in the morning may not be able to return or be sufficiently motivated.

Expect the count to be delayed tonight. There will be a unusually large number of provisional ballots to count and the closing time for the polls may be delayed.

8 comments:

Anonymous said...

Its not clear the provisional votes count at all!

From the state board of elections website FAQ -see the last line:

"What is a Provisional Ballot?
A provisional ballot is a safeguard to ensure that an individual who asserts that he or she is registered and eligible to vote will not be prevented from voting. A provisional ballot will only be counted after the County Election Board has reviewed the provisional ballot application and determined that the individual is registered and eligible to vote. You must be eligible to receive a provisional ballot. A provisional ballot cast by a voter who was ineligible to vote provisionally may be rejected. A provisional ballot is not an alternative to the electronic voting system."

http://www.elections.state.md.us/registered_voters/election_day_faq.html

Bruce Godfrey said...

Donna Edwards could be affected substantially by this.

Anonymous said...

I think this about sums up the extent of this "disaster"

During a morning news conference, many candidates in Montgomery County expressed concern that voters had been disenfranchised. Douglas F. Gansler, a Democratic candidate for attorney general, said that at least 35 people had left his polling place because of long lines

Come on...

Anonymous said...

So - why was Tom Perez's name still on the ballot?

Anonymous said...

I tried to vote at Silver Spring International School this morning. I was told I had already voted absentee. It took me 45 minutes to get and fill out a provisional ballot (I can arrive at work late without consequences).

Later I realized I hadn't voted for school board. Don't know if it wasn't on the provisional ballot or if I somehow missed it.

The poll workers tried very hard to be helpful, but as one said without a hint of irony, "it's been a long day." This was at 9 a.m.

Anonymous said...

Just an observation: for those folks working to get the Diebold machines removed from service, now would be a great time to commission a survey of Montgomery county voters to get feedback on their satisfaction with the machines.

I suspect the public opinion will be low enough to give a mandate for some drastic action to be taken.

Once I showed up at my poll they had already gotten in the ID cards, but they had to swipe multiple (4+ cards) before they finally found one that would work and allow me to vote. It hardly inspired much confidence in the system.

Anonymous said...

People who are comfortable with computers and modern technology forget that a large proportion of our population is still living without computers, without cell phones...so the result is older, retired volunteers working the polls who may not know how to use the cell phone they are given or have prowess with monitors and touch-screen technology. Then, too, the system changes for each election...

Anonymous said...

As a poll watcher for one of the candidates, I was able to observe the election judges, after the polls closed, trying to work with the machines to get the votes from roughly 12 machines to tabulate. It was not exactly confidence-inspiring, and took almost 90 minutes to do. While it seemed to work out okay at our polling station in the end, I can easily imagine some technologically-challenged judges having a really tough time with the flash memory cards from each machine. Definitely more training is required.