Showing posts with label Jerry Weast. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Jerry Weast. Show all posts

Tuesday, August 24, 2010

On Hearing Today of Jerry Weast’s Retirement Plans…

By Steve Simon.

As my former boss, MCPS Superintendent Jerry Weast, announces his retirement today, I will say… there are all kinds of leaders. Most people recognize that he has been anything but “lukewarm” in his leadership style and sometimes, as a result, he comes off as brash and uncompromising. And sometimes he is. Yes, the threat of “suing the county” to secure the school system’s funding this year was one example!

But – is he a visionary and a passionate educator? Absolutely. Has he been innovative and effective in successfully leading a school district through a massive sea change in student demographics? You bet. Does he work hard? Every day. Does he care about the kids? Most definitely, he does.

One of my most pleasing moments during a short career at MCPS was to see the Wall Street Journal showcase the school system, on page A1, as a system that used a “data-driven” approach to improve academic outcomes for students and close the achievement gap.

Does Dr. Weast deserve credit for leading that successful approach, for more than a decade? Once again, the answer is “yes.” All the credit? Of course not, and he recognizes that, always reminding “the troops” that success in the classroom starts with a great teacher, but depends on a great administrative team, support staff, the building maintenance team, and on and on.

As one who had a chance to witness his leadership style up close, I will say this: some of us may only occasionally get a front-row seat to observe a high-octane, high-performing, and yet, at times, hard-nosed CEO of a $2 billion-plus, 142,000-student, 22,000-employee operation in action. I did, in the case of Dr. Weast, and I feel fortunate for having had the experience.

A lot will be said about the guy between now and next June, but, from my vantage point, all of the things I have noted are true. Much more will be said and should be said about what brand of leader will be needed at a new point in Montgomery County history, from that when Jerry Weast entered the scene in what was still the 20th century! All of a sudden, the upcoming Board of Education elections seem more important than ever, don’t they?

But for today, at this time, I hope even his most persistent detractors – and bloggers – might pause at least briefly and recognize that it’s time to simply say: “Thank you, Dr. Weast. Good luck and enjoy what life has in store for you next.”

-- Steve Simon, owner of Simon Public Relations, LLC, is the former public information director for Montgomery County Public Schools.

Read More...

Tuesday, May 25, 2010

Consequences of the Budget, Part Two

One of the most compelling elements of the budget drama was its impact on the county’s most important government institution: its public schools.

The School System

The schools are a unique part of county government in four ways. First, their policies are set by a separate group of elected officials – the Board of Education. Second, the Superintendent is extremely powerful both by the nature of his position and, in the specific case of Jerry Weast, by the nature of his personality, intelligence and longevity. Third, the school system’s three unions – the teachers, SEIU Local 500 (which represents support staff) and the supervisors – are very influential and can move the schools’ political agenda in ways that its administrators cannot. Finally, school funding is protected by the state’s Maintenance of Effort (MOE) law, which requires counties to match the prior year’s per-pupil local funding to be eligible for state aid increases. For all of these reasons, the school budget is harder for the County Executive and the County Council to cut than the rest of the government. When the system’s needs clashed with the gigantic budget deficit, it was truly a case of an irresistible force colliding with an immoveable object.

This time, the immoveable object gave way under enormous pressure. Soon after the school board approved Weast’s $2.263 billion budget, the school system opened negotiations with the Executive branch over what the Executive’s proposal to the council would be. Weast’s budget met MOE requirements, but the Leggett administration needed a lower number to make the rest of the budget work. The two agreed on a $137 million cut from the school budget and the Executive transmitted this to the council. But then three things happened: a revenue writedown, warnings from bond rating agencies about the county’s AAA rating and the County Council’s reconciliation list. The first two added pressure for more cuts, while the last item requires explanation.

Every year, the budget process begins when the Executive sends a proposal to the council. The council then goes about adding spending items back in, which go onto a document called a “reconciliation list.” The cost of the items on that list must be reconciled, or paid for, by tax hikes or spending cuts elsewhere in the government. This year’s list contained $15 million of spending added to the Executive’s proposal. At one point, it was more than $22 million.

The school system was furious at the prospect that the County Council might take the money needed for its reconciliation items out of the schools’ budget. In the system’s view, they had already agreed to go below MOE by $137 million and to support the county’s application for a state waiver. Now the council wanted even more money to support items that the school system saw as frivolous. This was part of the motivation for Weast’s threat of litigation. He simply believed he had given up enough.

The county came much closer to litigation than most people knew. Last Wednesday at 11 AM, word went out through Rockville that the school board was calling a press conference at 1 PM to announce a lawsuit. The council was scheduled to take a straw vote on the budget at 1:30 PM. This set off a mad scramble among elected officials and school system leaders to cut a deal. At that point, only $1.6 million separated the two sides. The council came down by $600,000 and the deal was set: the schools would suffer an extra $24.4 million in cuts from the Executive’s budget. Weast and the school board GRUDGINGLY accepted it and disaster was averted.

The school system fared decently. It did not suffer nearly as big a cut as most county agencies and its employees will not be subject to furloughs. It now accounts for 57% of the county’s budget, its highest percentage in recent memory. But the conflict has had a steep medium-term cost. One Rockville source put it this way:

The threat of litigation was the single most dangerous and stupid miscalculation Jerry Weast has ever made. Had the school system gone ahead and sued the county, it is highly likely the Wall Street rating agencies would have downgraded the county’s General Obligation bond rating. This would have increased the cost of borrowing for the capital budget and slowed the county’s ability to modernize and replace aging school buildings. Even with the litigation threat removed, the county is not out of the woods in terms of the risk of a downgrade…

While the school system’s legal argument was shaky to begin with, the fact that it now will not sue completely discredits their argument. Never again can they make the dubious claim that the County Council has no right to reduce the schools’ appropriation below the amount recommended by the County Executive because a judge will rightly ask, “But the council did precisely that in 2010. Why didn’t you challenge them then?”
Another spy added:

Weast so overplayed his hand he almost brought everyone down with him.
For all his talent, record of achievement and force of personality, Jerry Weast has hit the end of the road with the County Council. The council’s Education Committee chair openly calls him a “Rogue Superintendent.” Few if any Council Members trust his budget numbers. When he claims to submit a “bare bones budget,” no one on the council believes him even if it is true. All of them think Weast has squirreled away secret stashes of money in his $2+ billion budget. There is no longer any fear of Weast in Rockville as even his long-time allies at the Washington Post threw him under the bus less than two months after asking the county to keep him on. Whether Weast’s approach is right or wrong, he and the council are now oil and water that will never mix again.

Tomorrow, we’ll look at the unions.

Read More...

Tuesday, May 11, 2010

School Board Authorizes Lawsuit Against County

MCPS Superintendent Jerry Weast asked for and received authorization from the Board of Education to sue the county if the County Council cuts the system's budget below the level proposed by the County Executive. The Post reports that the authorization was unanimous. Following is the text of the resolution approved by the board.

Office of the Superintendent of Schools
Montgomery County Public Schools
Rockville, Maryland
May 11, 2010

MEMORANDUM

To: Members of the Board of Education

From: Jerry D. Weast, Superintendent of Schools

Subject: Authorization for Legal Action Related to the Board of Educations’ FY 2011 Operating Budget

WHEREAS, In the last two fiscal years, the school system’s budget has been reduced and savings totaling $223,000,000 made available to the County through hiring freezes, expenditure restrictions, cuts in existing services, and the agreement of our 22,000 employees to forego any cost-of-living salary adjustment; and

WHEREAS, The Board of Education and the superintendent of schools worked cooperatively with the Montgomery County Executive to balance the needs of the school system, its 22,000 employees and its 142,000 students with the fiscal realities facing local government; and

WHEREAS, The Board of Education and the superintendent of schools, for the second year in a row, are supporting and joining with the County Council and the County Executive to seek a waiver of the County’s obligation to fund so-called “maintenance of effort” from the Maryland State Board of Education; and

WHEREAS, The requested waiver effectively would reduce the school system’s budget by an additional $137,700,000 and subject the school system to a decrease in state education funding of up to $51,300,000, if the waiver is not granted; and

WHEREAS, Further reductions by the Council to the school system’s budget below that recommended by the County Executive will most certainly trigger a penalty of up to $51,300,000 in state aid even if the State Board of Education approves the County’s request for a waiver of maintenance of effort; and

WHEREAS, These significant reductions in the school system’s budget come at a time when the school system’s enrollment increased by approximately 4,000 students over the past two years, including a 10 percent increase in the number of students receiving Free and Reduced-price Meals System services in just one year, so that nearly one-third of elementary school students are eligible to receive subsidized meals; and

WHEREAS, An additional reduction of at least $30,000,000 proposed by some members of the County Council will threaten the education reforms that have resulted in record student achievement and could lead to a significant dismantling of the school system’s programs in this County; and

WHEREAS, Additional reductions of at least $30,000,000 combined with a potential state penalty of $51,300,000 will be very difficult, if not impossible, to implement before the opening of school, and

WHEREAS, The students and families rely on the school system to provide nutrition, often not available elsewhere, and an education that is closing the gap and providing students with the ability to enter college and to enter careers to become productive citizens and taxpayers; and

WHEREAS, The Board of Education has a fiduciary duty to provide the education our students require to secure their futures and a statutory duty, pursuant to Section 4-101 of the Education Article, to promote the interests of the schools under our jurisdiction; and

WHEREAS, The County Council is without legal authority to reduce the school system’s budget beyond reductions made by the County Executive when the level of funding he proposes is below the level required by state law to maintain the effort; now therefore be it

RESOLVED, That legal counsel representing the Board of Education and the school system are hereby authorized to take any and all appropriate legal action to prevent the County Council from exceeding its authority by making any further reductions in the County Executive’s recommendation for the FY 2011 Operating Budget for Montgomery County Public Schools.

JDW:BKE:dh

Read More...

Thursday, May 06, 2010

Weast Whips the Council!

From Fox 5:

Read More...

Monday, March 08, 2010

MCPS Prepares to Cut Positions, Increase Class Size

MCPS Superintendent Jerry Weast sent a memo to the Board of Education and an email to MCPS staff on Friday indicating his intention to cut 252 classroom positions in the schools, thereby increasing MCPS class size by one student per class. Weast is taking this step because he anticipates that his budget request will not be fully funded and the school system needs to begin planning its staff allocations for the next school year now. We have run the ugly budget numbers before and this is the first sign of many of their tangible effects on county services. No one is safe. The County Executive is due to present his operating budget proposal next week.

Following are Weast’s memo to the Board of Education and his message to MCPS staff.

#####

Office of the Superintendent of Schools
Montgomery County Public Schools
Rockville, Maryland

March 5, 2010

Memorandum

To: Members of the Board of Education
From: Jerry D. Weast, Superintendent of Schools
Subject: FY 2011 Staff Allocations to Schools

This memorandum is to inform you about the preliminary steps that are being taken to prepare for the possibility that the County Executive and the County Council will substantially reduce the Board’s requested Fiscal Year 2011 Operating Budget. Our normal process calls for allocations for schools to be made during the first week of March for the following school year. In making these allocations, I believe it is prudent that we plan for significant reductions in allocations because of the difficult fiscal times we are facing. If we do not make this assumption and allocate positions to schools based on the Board’s request budget, and the County Council makes substantial reductions in May 2010, we could have to eliminate hundreds of school-based positions in early June 2010 and begin the involuntary transfer process at a time when teachers and other 10-month employees would be leaving school for the summer. We expect that these allocations will cause significant concerns, but the disruption will be far less than if we had to make these cuts during the summer.

Schools receive their staff allocations for the upcoming year on March 5, 2010. Principals have three weeks to identify teachers and other staff that have to be involuntarily transferred. Position vacancies will be posted by principals at the end of March. The job fair for teachers will be held the week of April 19, and the voluntary transfer process will begin on April 23. The voluntary transfer process will continue until May 28, 2010. At that time, the offices of Human Resources and School Performance will begin to place all involuntarily transferred staff members who have not been offered positions during the transfer process. Once all involuntary transfers are placed in a subject or grade level, the voluntary transfer process will reopen. The Office of Human Resources will then begin to hire new teachers from outside Montgomery County Public Schools (MCPS). Previously, hiring began prior to June using the “open contract” process in which new hires were given a contract, but were not assigned to schools until all involuntarily transferred staff members were assigned to schools. This year, because of the uncertainty of the situation, open contracts will be offered in only a few selected areas of need, such as special education.

If we wait to reduce school allocations until after the County Council takes action on the budget, the allocation, transfer and hiring processes would begin three months later than usual, and it would be impossible to complete the process by August 2010, when school begins. The uncertainties and anxieties that this would create would have a tremendous impact on our schools next fall. The plan we have initiated is intended to make the process as smooth as possible given the difficult fiscal constraints. In the event that the County Council does not make reductions to the MCPS budget, it will be much easier to allocate additional positions to the schools in June than it would be to begin reducing schools’ allocations at that time.

In the operating budget that I recommended to the Board in December 2009, I included a list of possible reductions that might have to be considered if the County Council did not approve full funding of the budget request. We have used this list of possible reductions as the basis for the allocations that were made to schools this week. We have assumed some of these reductions, but not all of them. Some of the reductions would impact so many staff members that we would not be able to place all of them in positions in the fall, and some of the reductions would have required us to reduce the numbers of hours of employment for hundreds of staff. Although we may still have to make these reductions in June 2010, depending on the final actions of the County Council, my goal is to keep “Reductions in Force” (layoffs) and the number of staff who lose hours of employment to a minimum. But, this will depend on final County Council action.

Classroom teacher allocation formulas have been adjusted to increase class size by one student per class. This has resulted in holding 252 positions in reserve: 142 in elementary school, 55 in middle school and 55 in high school. These positions are in addition to the classroom teacher reserve that is held to address schools where enrollment increases result in an unmanageable number of oversized classes. In addition, 80 other teacher positions have been held in reserve. These include special program, staff development, focus, and academic intervention teachers and media specialists. Approximately 30 paraeducator positions also have been held in reserve. Furthermore, a plan is being developed to notify central services staff whose positions might be eliminated so that they may have the opportunity to seek positions in schools during the scheduled voluntary transfer process.

If we ultimately have to eliminate these positions that are being held in reserve, there will be a significant impact on schools. If you have any questions, please contact Mr. Larry A. Bowers, chief operating officer, at 301-279-3626.

JDW: LAB: ndm

Copy to:

Executive Staff
Ms. Cuttitta
Mr. Ikheloa
Dr. Newman
Mr. Prouty
Ms. Romero

#####

From: Administrator
Sent: Friday, March 05, 2010 1:36 PM
Subject: A Message to Staff from Dr. Weast Concerning Staffing Allocations

Dear Staff:

I continue to be impressed with the exceptional work you do every day on behalf of the children of Montgomery County Public Schools (MCPS). Despite these difficult economic times, you have kept a positive attitude and focused on our core mission of preparing every child for the world beyond our doors. And the results continue to be impressive with student achievement increasing at every level.

I have spoken with many of you about the trying economic environment we are in and the budget difficulties we are facing. And you have shared with me your anxieties and uncertainties about what the future holds. I want to reassure you that our leadership team and I are committed to doing everything we can to preserve jobs and avoid layoffs, if possible. The unfortunate reality is that there will be painful cuts ahead as we work to balance the budget.

As you know, staffing season is just beginning. We have made the decision to make reductions in staff allocations this spring to prepare for what we believe are inevitable cuts. If we do not make this assumption and allocate positions to schools based on the Board of Education's requested budget and the County Council makes substantial funding reductions, we could have to eliminate hundreds of school-based positions in early June. That would delay the involuntary transfer process to a time when teachers and other 10-month employees are leaving school for the summer. I don't believe that is fair to our employees and that's why we are reducing the allocations now.

The most significant change in the staffing plan is the increase in class size by one student. This will result in the elimination of 252 positions - 142 in elementary schools and 55 each at the middle and high school levels. There are other reductions in the allocations as well, some of which are driven by enrollment fluctuations. Principals will be discussing the allocation changes and the involuntary transfer process with staff members over the next three weeks. Again, our goal is to be able to place staff members in vacant positions, but we cannot guarantee that we will be able to avoid layoffs at the end of this process. If there is a need for layoffs, they will be implemented in accord with the collective bargaining agreements.

In addition to school staffing reductions, significant cuts also will be made to central services. Over the last two years, we have cut $18 million from the central office budget and we expect to make another $6 million in cuts. These will be challenging cuts and will impact the support we provide to schools, but they are necessary to confront the worsening fiscal situation.

I realize that this news is disturbing, but I believe it is important to keep you informed of the budget situation. The County Executive will submit his recommended budget to the County Council on March 15. The Council is expected to approve a budget by mid-May, which is when we will know what our final budget will be. We will provide further updates to you as the budget process progresses.

Again, thank you for all you do for our children. I know that, despite the additional challenges we will be facing, our staff will continue to provide the best possible education for every student.

Respectfully,

Jerry D. Weast, Ed.D.

Superintendent of Schools

Read More...

Tuesday, December 22, 2009

Weast Blasts Elrich

In a wide-ranging interview with the Montgomery County Sentinel, MCPS Superintendent Jerry Weast singled out County Council Member Marc Elrich, a former fifth grade public school teacher, for special scorn. And the Weast War continues!

In a November 9 statement on this blog, Elrich noted that the state's Maintenance of Effort law made no exceptions for savings from labor concessions or administrative efficiencies. Weast took exception to that in the Sentinel's interview. Here is the entire text of the relevant question and answer.

The Sentinel:
Some of the county council members disagreed with your actions to ask the state attorney general if the alternative solution to the MOE waiver denial was the right thing to do. What is your response to that?

Weast:
The problem with that is that they don't have to sign an official document to the state certifying that it is legal.

I think if they did, they would have taken a different approach to it.

I guess it depends on whom is signing the check. I have to legally sign that what they did was accurate and since there was a question, I had to check the legality of it.

As soon as I checked the legality of it - because had I signed it without checking it out, I would have been signing an illegal document.

What I am baffled by is that what one of the Council members, Marc Elrich, posted on the [Maryland Politics Watch] blog that I should have just ignored it and pretended the law didn't exist.

I've never heard of an elected official wanting to ignore the law. I mean, if you want to write some controversy in your paper then there's your controversy right there.

My goodness. Just quote that blog posting. It's one elected official telling another to ignore the law on a form that carries a $46 million penalty. Hello? Houston we have a problem. I've never like confined spaces with bars in front of them.
Weast is understandably frustrated because the school system is facing tens of millions of dollars in penalties due to an accounting maneuver that he did not commit. But in re-reading Elrich's statement, we cannot find evidence that Elrich advised Weast to break the law. Furthermore, when Weast refers to "one elected official telling another to break the law," we should note that Jerry Weast is a contract employee hired by the Board of Education and not an elected office holder.

Read More...

Monday, December 14, 2009

Weast War

And so it has begun. MCPS Superintendent Jerry Weast has fired the first shot in what may be his last and greatest battle: the fight over the Fiscal Year 2011 school budget. Pull up your chairs, folks, because you are about to see the master at work.

Weast’s opening salvo was a double-down special in the Post and the Gazette, plus an appearance on News Channel 8. He has drafted both an “as is,” or bare-bones, budget and a list of cuts if it is not funded. (The latter tactic reminds us of the state’s infamous “doomsday cuts” that were rolled out just before the 2007 special session.) Weast’s budget is based on the premise that the county will at least match the per-pupil local spending of FY 2010, which is the state “maintenance of effort” (MOE) requirement. On its face, it is entirely reasonable for the Superintendent to expect that the county will comply with state law.

Of course, the budget assumes that school system employees will be granted $25.9 million more in step increases, which are salary hikes for employees gaining seniority within their existing classifications. That virtually matches the overall budget increase of $25.2 million. But Weast has not negotiated new contracts with the school system’s three unions: the Supervisors, SEIU Local 500 and MCEA. There is no assurance that county employees in the rest of the government will get step increases or that the County Council will support them. So if Weast does not negotiate step increases, the budget will drop by $25.9 million with no direct impact on the classroom.

But there may be sanction from the state. MOE demands that the county must match its prior year’s per-pupil funding level to be eligible for state aid. No exception is made for reduced labor compensation, a point made by Council Member Marc Elrich on this blog. Council Member Valerie Ervin has labeled MOE a “crazy law” and some state legislators are discussing how to make it easier for the counties to get waivers and spend less. But that will not sit well with Weast, who says that any cut to his proposed budget will have “a devastating impact on the children.”

Nor will it be tolerated by MCEA, which is still the county’s undisputed 800-pound gorilla. MCEA has posted a lengthy analysis of MOE on its website, which contains this statement:

The MCEA Board of Directors has approved the following position statements on Maintenance of Effort:

MCEA supports legislative action to waive the soon-to-be-announced multi-million dollar “penalty” in loss of state education aid to Montgomery County for the 2009-2010.

MCEA supports legislative action to ensure that future “penalties” not be imposed on local school systems for actions taken by others (the county councils).

MCEA opposes any erosion of the – already minimalist – definition of Maintenance of Effort.
Additionally, MCEA President Doug Prouty’s appearance on News Channel 8 and MCEA Executive Director Tom Israel’s comments on this blog make plain that the union regards any weakening of the MOE law as injurious to education. In that position, they are in lockstep with Weast.

And so Weast is digging in his heels and unsheathing his many weapons to fight back. Just as he told the media, he will not settle for a dime less than what is guaranteed by MOE. He will probably not be doing the county any favors by taking the lead in labor negotiations, which is what he did a year ago. Why should he? Weast’s reward for making the county’s labor renegotiations with the non-school unions easier was the MOE debacle. On top of all this, Weast’s press release states that he is “repurposing the $79.5 million placed in the budget by the County Council in FY 2010 to pay for county debt service. Instead, that money will be used to meet rising costs.” In other words, all deals under discussion to cope with MOE last spring are off. Weast is not about to be double-crossed again.

It is very unwise to bet against Jerry Weast and the 800-pound gorilla except for one thing. Their enemy is not the County Council or the state government. Their enemy is an entity of nearly unlimited power and no remorse: the county’s moribund economy, which is now an exploding grenade spraying shrapnel in MANY directions. The horrible state and county budgets, the requirements of state law, the immense political pressure directed by Weast and the unions and the looming specter of the 2010 elections are all about to collide.

Which will be blown to smithereens first?

Read More...

Thursday, December 10, 2009

Weast: "Devastating Impact on the Children"

Read More...

Thursday, December 03, 2009

The Rogue Superintendent, Part Four

The worsening relationship between MCPS Superintendent Jerry Weast and the County Council combined with Weast’s scheduled departure in 2011 calls into question the future of the school system. Let’s move beyond the politics and look at the facts on the ground.

1. In 1970, roughly 95% of Montgomery County public school students were white. Today, they are 38% white, 23% African American, 23% Latino and 16% Asian American. MCPS claims it has students from more than 164 countries speaking 134 languages. This is an incredibly diverse student body.


2. The percentage of students receiving free or reduced price meals has risen from 22% of enrollees in FY 2001 to 27% today. English-for speakers-of-other-language (ESOL) students have grown from 7% of enrollees in FY 2001 to 12% today. These students require extra effort to help them achieve at the same levels as wealthy children or English speakers.

3. Despite these challenges, a higher percentage of MCPS African American students scored a 3 or higher on Advanced Placement exams (19.6%) than did all students nationwide (15.2%) in the Class of 2008. Latinos did even better (32.2%). MCPS scores were superior to the average for Maryland, which is ranked as the number one statewide public school system in the country.


4. Between 2000 and 2008, every demographic category of the student body recorded massive increases in both the number of Advanced Placement exams taken and the number of scores at 3 or higher. The numbers went up even more in 2009. This is extremely important for college preparation.


5. For the Class of 2001, 28.9% of MCPS African American students earned a college degree – very close to the national average for all students (29.6%). The rate for MCPS Latinos (24.2%) was not much lower.


Given the demographic context for MCPS, the odds-on result would be falling performance. But MCPS has more than held its own. If that success is to continue, the following issues must be addressed.

1. ESOL students and free-and-reduced meal students are only going to increase as a percentage of the student body. That imposes rising costs on the school system that the county cannot escape. It must either fund those costs and support efforts to adequately educate these students or the system’s quality will fall.

2. The county is in sharp competition with other school districts for talent. Fairfax is competitive with MCPS in every way. D.C. Superintendent Michelle Rhee may ultimately succeed in pushing through a massive pay increase for teachers who forgo tenure. And even though Frederick and Howard Counties may pay less in teacher salaries, their cost of living is much lower than in Montgomery County. While the county may not be able to afford significant wage increases for the moment, many more years of low or non-existent wage hikes will hit Montgomery’s teacher talent base hard.

3. The Board of Education and the County Council are weary of Jerry Weast’s power and his ready willingness to use it. They may be tempted to pick a weakling to succeed him. That will only damage the school system. Weast’s successor must be a strong leader who continues to collaborate with labor, encourages innovative programs like peer-assisted review for teachers, spreads money around to poorer schools and focuses relentlessly on measurable outcomes.

The stakes are high and go far, far beyond clashes of power and ego. Montgomery County is in a fierce economic competition with Fairfax whether its leaders sufficiently appreciate that fact or not. Fairfax has lower taxes than Montgomery in every category except property. The one factor that keeps Montgomery in the game is that its public schools match those in Fairfax. So the county’s leaders will have to bear down and focus on keeping that edge.

Even if it means another eighteen months of dealing with the Rogue Superintendent.

Read More...

Wednesday, December 02, 2009

The Rogue Superintendent, Part Three

Is Council Member Valerie Ervin right when she says that MCPS Superintendent Jerry Weast is a rogue? Here’s what our informant network had to say.

Spy #1:

No, I do not agree. He is simply trying to look out for the school system, and keep it most viable and effective. They [the County Council] should not be surprised by this behavior. They have seen it over the last 10 years.
Spy #2:

It was a little “rogue” to send that letter to Grasmick without talking to the council - essentially drawing attention to the [maintenance of effort] issue. But, on the whole, I think most people have a problem with him because he is political and people feel that a school superintendent shouldn’t be so political. My opinion is his political nature has been a benefit to the school system - he knows how to get things done.
Spy #3:

If by “rogue” Valerie Ervin means operating outside normal or desirable controls, of course he is. He’s been a rogue since he arrived. Now it just looks like he is setting himself up for another contract when his current one expires. He appears to be standing up for “the kids,” but he’s really posturing before the Board and the unions, positioning himself as the only viable successor to himself. Don’t be surprised to see him use the MOE money he gets in the next budget to fund COLA and step increases for school system employees. With Jerry Weast, it is – and always has been – first and foremost about Jerry Weast. And that’s why he meets another definition of “rogue:” an unprincipled, deceitful, and unreliable person.
Spy #4:

Weast is very adept at getting his way with the school board, politicians and others, and he has produced results. The man has a lot of power. I do find his “Gosh, gee whiz we’re going to work on that” act a little hard to stomach. He kind of reminds me of a combination of Opie Taylor and Rahm Emanuel - smiling country boy with brass knuckles hidden behind his back. Does that make him rogue? I don’t know, but I am very fond of Valerie Ervin and consider her opinion as something to be taken seriously.
Spy #5:

At the federal level, it’s rarely helpful to have Generals or Cabinet Secretaries disagreeing in public with the President. In the same vein, the County is best served when it speaks with one voice on contentious dealings with the State. Where agency heads or other County employees decide to pursue their own independent agendas with the State or seek to undercut our County’s duly elected representatives in their dealings with the State, describing such an individual as a “rogue” employee is entirely appropriate.
Spy #6:

I do not think Dr. Weast is a Rogue Superintendent. In fact, I credit him with maintaining one of the best school systems in the country. Obviously, he was provided the tools to succeed with increased education dollars over the years; and the teachers, support staff, and others are part of our success, too. However, I still believe he deserves a good amount of credit. During his tenure, the school system has become even larger and more diverse; there are more students needing English as a second language; and there are more lower-income families in the system and those with greater needs. Yet, we have seen continued progress in closing the achievement gap, more minority students taking AP exams, and our schools continue to maintain high marks when compared to other school systems throughout the country.

Maryland has been rated nationally as having the number one school system in the country; Montgomery County schools can take a big part of the credit for that recognition. Being #1 does not happen by accident. Dr. Weast has done a great job considering the challenges.
Spy #7:

Rogue is an understatement. He’s irresponsible at best, a tyrant, a bully, abusive and worse. I’ve heard from board members who’ve been threatened by him in ways that I, and probably a court, would consider blackmail in order to get their acquiescence on a vote. Add into that his willingness to interfere in politics. School wise, he’s driven teachers from the schools, he wastes money on so-called “research indicates” programs that change almost as fast as seasons. His training for teachers are the ed equivalent of drive-by shootings. He over-looked or was involved with the Porter scandal, well covered up, where we buy this palm-based assessment program from his failing company. Carrasco gets caught using school facilities for his private company, during school hours, and Weast promotes him up into the administrative hierarchy rather than firing him.
Spy #8:

Of course he’s rogue, that's why he’s been so effective in the past. But I think he’s done more for the school system than any other single person in county history. That happened because he came in with new ideas and the energy to get them done. Now, he’s a little tired from all the political fights and he’s settled in ideologically in such a way that he is now as much a barrier to school reform as a driver of it. He has also become more reliant on bureaucrats who could care less about kids in poverty or making the schools better. So the question for Weast is this: go out on a high note as one of the most widely respected and innovative superintendents in the country, or fade slowly into obscurity, increasingly undercutting a reputation for brilliant reform by opposing new reforms. And the question for Montgomery County is this: do we want to keep putting our schools on the cutting edge, or do we want to rest on our laurels?
Spy #9:

I think people need to decide if they want a really nice guy, whom everyone loves, and gets rolled over by the County Council and County Executive, and have a mediocre school system, or do they want someone who holds his own, may not always be the most popular, holds out for the school system, and has one of the top school systems in the country? I don’t think there are too many people out there that could do it both ways.

Jerry has done more for the unions than any previous superintendent, both in terms of wages and benefits. There has been more involvement by the community, PTA’s, unions in the budget, policy making, major decisions, than with any other superintendent ever. There has been more openness with this superintendent than ever before. I don’t believe there is another school system in the country that has made the strides we have in minority achievement, even with the transformation of our school system from majority white to majority minority. Dr. Weast is respected nationwide for his education initiatives, and is constantly asked for advice by the USDE.

Does Dr. Weast ruffle some feathers and have people dislike him? Absolutely! I can’t imagine doing his job well without getting some people upset.
The opinions of our informants reflect the split in the county’s political community over Weast’s style and his value to the schools. We believe that Weast has lost political capital for two reasons.

1. A solid majority of the County Council agrees with Council Member Valerie Ervin’s statement to the Gazette that Weast is indeed a rogue. They are tired of a non-elected official holding so much power, running a separate organization with its own PR operation and making them look bad in the press. Weast makes no effort to massage politicians’ egos or to recognize both the rest of the county government’s budgetary needs as well as the office holders’ political needs. The contempt for Weast in Rockville has approached such a boiling point that he may be a net debit for the school system in terms of appealing to the County Council.

2. Weast’s three sources of leverage are diminishing. First, his in-house media outreach efforts are likely to be contradicted in public by elected office holders much more so than in the past. That will muddy the press coverage of MCPS and its needs.

Second, Weast’s allies on the Washington Post Editorial Board are both more restive and less powerful. A recent Post editorial warned Weast to not bargain any wage increases with the school unions, meaning that the newspaper’s traditional affection for Weast may be overtaken by its fiscal conservatism and anti-union outlook. Furthermore, the Post’s editorial credibility was severely damaged by the Boy King scandal. The Post’s editorial page (including its national and international columns) has just 185 Google subscribers, a lower total than MPW (262) or Just Up the Pike (239). In the online world, the Post’s editorials do not have as much reach as is commonly believed.

Third, Weast’s most powerful collaborator – MCEA – will be working on the margins in the next county election. No District Council Members have declared opponents at this point. On the At-Large side, George Leventhal is a strong bet for re-election with or without the Apple Ballot and Nancy Floreen has won without MCEA’s endorsement before. All of this means that the majority of the County Council Members will be returning with or without MCEA’s help, which reduces the union’s leverage. Furthermore, the horrendous budget situation will give the council an excuse to kill any new initiative if they so choose, even one supported by Weast and the unions.

Weast is a compelling figure and his relationship with the County Council makes for great political theater. But there is a far more important issue at stake: the future of the school system. We will conclude by examining that issue in Part Four.

Read More...

Tuesday, December 01, 2009

The Rogue Superintendent, Part Two

One reason why Montgomery County is struggling so much over its maintenance of effort (MOE) issue is the rocky relationship between the County Council and its “Rogue Superintendent,” Jerry Weast. Why does Weast attract so much resentment from Rockville?

History will look back on Jerry Weast as a towering figure in Montgomery County. He is brilliant, nationally respected, full of energy and devoid of fear. He can also be a head-cracking administrator who is dismissive of opponents. What he builds through his creativity and hard work is sometimes tarnished by his self-aggrandizing nature. He has long had a reputation for riding rough-shod over his board, occasionally talking down to them “as your leader.” Your author once participated in a joint meeting with Weast, a Council Member and several other officials and actually witnessed Weast holding forth on the political prospects of that Council Member as if that person was not in the room! But Weast’s ego, as hard as it may be to take, has also helped him to score victories in situations when a lesser superintendent would have backed down.

Some of Weast’s most important wins have been budgetary. Total MCPS enrollment has not risen much during his term, from 134,180 in FY 2001 (his first budget) to a projected 137,727 in FY 2010. But the cost per pupil has soared from $8,166 to $14,294 over the same period. Some of that cost has stemmed from the increase in students receiving free or reduced price meals from 22% of enrollees in FY 2001 to 27% today. Another cost generator has been the increase in English-for speakers-of-other-language (ESOL) students from 7% of enrollees in FY 2001 to 12% today. Weast has employed a combination of political savvy, ruthlessness and media outreach to make sure those needs are met. Weast has also focused on reducing the test score and graduation gap between different demographic groups and has met with some success. One source with experience in the school system comments, “He may be an [expletive deleted], but he gets things done.”

Weast is a relentless data-driven manager. Everywhere he goes, he carries reams of charts and statistics demonstrating both his challenges and his triumphs. And if he can’t carry enough data himself, he will bring along subordinates with even more. He uses this information to enforce an Empire of Numbers inside his domain. He wants results, results, RESULTS and he reacts poorly to excuses. This constant focus on statistics is both a mark of Weast’s competency and a weakness. Nervous parents value compassion, sensitivity and a willingness to listen. Politicians value deference and diplomacy. Such qualities are seldom shown by Montgomery’s hard-charging superintendent, a man who will never understand why others do not value data as much as he does.

Weast’s influence reaches far outside MCPS. He has cleverly cultivated the county’s school unions, involving them in formulating his budgets and implementing many policies. He has also rewarded good performance with generous contracts. Weast’s collaborative style on labor-management relations, including his use of peer reviews for teachers, contrasts starkly with heavy-handed D.C. Superintendent Michelle Rhee and the vast majority of private sector firms.

Weast and the unions have a common interest in maximizing the school budget and they make for a formidable tag team. County Executive Ike Leggett learned that in 2007, when he recommended a slightly lower increase than Weast requested, only to see a giant rally of school advocates on the council building steps. Weast also has an independent line to the Washington Post and benefits from fawning coverage and glowing editorials. Weast even influences the Post’s election endorsements, whether directly or indirectly. In 2006, the Post declined to endorse then-appointed School Board Member Nancy Navarro on the grounds that “we are disturbed by what we see as her tepid support of Mr. Weast, whose contract comes up for renewal next year.” The triple threat of Weast’s in-house media operation, the strength of the unions and the support of the Post has proven to be too much for most politicians to handle.

The superintendent’s power is not limitless. Community pressure caused Weast to delay his plan to close the county’s special education centers and he was defeated outright in his attempt to close Seven Locks Elementary School in Bethesda. Weast caused an uproar when he urged union leaders to endorse Nancy Navarro in the 2008 County Council special election, a debacle that contributed to her loss. The Board of Education just voted down his attempt to close a small elementary school in the rural western part of the county. And Weast’s tenure has been marred by multiple scandals involving his subordinates. Those problems along with the dispute over maintenance of effort and recent test score issues have emboldened the growing ranks of his enemies.

So is Weast a rogue? We’ll ask our informants in Part Three.

Read More...

Monday, November 30, 2009

The Rogue Superintendent, Part One

County Council Member Valerie Ervin, the Chair of the Council’s Education Committee, recently called MCPS leader Jerry Weast a “rogue superintendent.” That statement is a culmination of years of tension between the County Council and the school system that has been recently exacerbated by budget difficulties. All of that is threatening to erupt in an all-out battle with consequences for the county’s future.

The immediate cause of this dispute is the county’s maintenance of effort (MOE) quandary. State law requires counties to spend at least as much local funding on education each fiscal year as they have the prior fiscal year. This year, Montgomery County asked the state for a waiver of that requirement in the amount of $79 million due to the poor state of the economy and the tax-limiting Ficker Amendment. The county’s Board of Education and Weast agreed with the grounds for a waiver and testified on its behalf. When the state denied the county’s request, the county arranged to give the school district the money to satisfy the state’s requirement, but took it back as a debt service charge for construction. Weast believed that the maneuver would apply just to one year, but the County Council refused to agree to that restriction. Weast then wrote State Superintendent of Schools Nancy Grasmick asking whether the county’s budget maneuver was legal, prompting an opinion by Attorney General Doug Gansler stating that it was not. That may subject the county to penalties ranging from $23-45 million in lost state aid. Weast then blasted the County Council in a statement that was sent to the media but not to the council, prompting Council Member Ervin, who oversees his budget, to denounce him as a “rogue.”

The immediate issue surrounding the penalty is pressing. The budget gimmick approved by the council sent $79 million to the school system so that that money could be used to pay off bonds to build schools. If the state’s penalty applies directly to the school system, it will likely be paid from the money that was to be used for the bonds. That would leave the county responsible for paying off those bonds from another source of money. But if the county makes the school system eat the money, the impact would be unpredictable.

All of this occurs in the background of severe budget problems. The county learned in November that income tax revenues due from the state are $85.2 million lower than originally projected. A County Council budget analysis states:

The total FY10 shortfall, based on the State’s new formula, could be in the range of $95 million, while the FY11 shortfall could be in the range of $110 million. These write downs alone could bring the County's estimated FY11 budget gap, which in September was projected at $364.4 million, to well over $500 million, despite the Council's November 17 approval of a $29.7 Savings Plan for FY10. Other factors could make the gap still larger.
In other words, no part of the county government has money laying around to pay off the penalty.

How did things get to this point? Multiple sources report that the school system offered the county a deal last spring to get around the $79 million MOE requirement. The terms of the deal were that the county would pay the schools the $79 million, but the schools would agree to hold the money in reserve. That money would then be available to finance next year’s budget. The reason that proposal fell apart was that many in Rockville did not trust Jerry Weast to sit on the money. And so the ill-fated budget gimmick was instituted, initiating the fall into the hole that the county now occupies.

That brings us back to a central factor that handicaps the ability of the county to respond to adversity: a basic distrust between Weast and some of the county’s elected officeholders. We’ll look more closely at that issue in Part Two.

Read More...

Saturday, November 07, 2009

Weast Throws Council Under the Bus on School Funding Dispute (Updated)

In a statement released to the media but not to County Council Members, MCPS Superintendent Jerry Weast puts the blame squarely on the council for the county's setback on school funding. Weast has long run an empire at MCPS, with an independent line to the Washington Post's editorial writers and a condescending attitude to his board and local elected officials. But the blunt language and threatening final paragraph in his statement is sure to draw fury from Rockville.

“I’m disappointed, but not surprised, at the Attorney General’s ruling. We had serious concerns that the County Council’s plan did not meet the Maintenance of Effort provision and, unfortunately, we were correct. Now, we may face a fine from the state and the brunt of that burden will be felt by our students and teachers at a very critical time.”

“We were trying to do the right thing: We wanted to help the county with its budget problems. We asked the state for a waiver of the MOE provision and we were denied. We offered suggestions and ideas to the County Council for legal ways we could help them and we were not listened to. In the end, we had a solution pushed upon us that, it turns out, was illegal. I guess no good deed goes unpunished.”

“Over the next several days, we will be discussing the impact of this ruling. I can promise you this: We will have a full Maintenance of Effort budget in fiscal year 2011. Never again will we put our employees and students in this position.”
Update: Council Member Valerie Ervin, Chair of the Council's Education Committee, has called Weast a “rogue superintendent.”

Read More...

Friday, October 02, 2009

Montgomery County’s Most Influential People, Part Five

Here are the five most influential non-elected people in the county. Their key advantage: you can’t vote against them to get rid of them!

5. Jon Gerson, Director of Community Outreach, Montgomery County Education Association
12 Votes

Reader: The political voice and face of MCEA, still the best endorsement in Montgomery County.

Reader: May not have the awesome power he had in 2006, but Gerson is still a kingmaker and MCEA is a force to be reckoned with.

Reader: The Apple Ballot still yields incredible power as a voter tool. I choose not to elaborate any further.

Reader: The much-hyped Apple Ballot is purported to drive at least 5% of voters, depending on who you ask. Whether you believe that or not, one thing is for sure, and that is that whether or not it leads to victory, it is definitely not a good thing for a politician to be off the Apple Ballot. Most of them know this, and so the Apple Ballot strategy is factored into most every campaign in the County.

Adam: This is all about respect for MCEA’s Apple Ballot, which remains the WMD of MoCo local politics. Pity the poor politician who gets caught in the blast zone.

4. Gino Renne, President, UFCW Local 1994, Municipal & County Government Employees Organization (MCGEO)
19 Votes

Reader: Labor’s top dog in Rockville.

Reader: The most militant labor leader in the county. Depending on whom you ask, that either makes him more or less effective.

Reader: Knows how to use union power. He even looks like an extra from the movie “Hoffa.”

Reader: MCEA, SEIU 500 and MCGEO are the three most important county unions, and among the most important political players in the county. Gino has Bob Stewart, who’s a tough organizer, and the two play hardball well.

Reader: Gino understands what we’re dealing with, takes the most hits of any union when it comes to loss of employee base and is still willing to try to work out a sustainable budget plan.

Reader: Great combination of brains and brawn!

Reader: They get their people out when needed and certainly make their voices heard. I may not always agree with the way they do things, but they are often effective.

Adam: After all these years, MCGEO’s fearsome overlord still knows how to break balls and bust heads.

3. Adam Pagnucco, Author, Maryland Politics Watch
30 Votes

Reader: No other nonprofit, lobbying outfit or media outlet produces the consistent churn of news, research, and other salacious tidbits that emerge from Maryland Politics Watch. It is no wonder that readership has skyrocketed in such a short time and that this blog’s coverage of local politics has now jumped leagues ahead of any mainstream media outlet. It is both a testament to Adam Pagnucco’s hard work and smarts, but also a statement of the disheveled state of our local news outlets. Politicians and advocates alike ignore Pagnucco’s blog to their peril.

Reader: His blog is the MoCo political bible.

Reader: Adam, you’ve taken this blog which had some nice analysis and made it a bit more pointed. Drives me crazy sometimes but everyone reads it. And you actually listen to people and report and analyze intelligently. Ironically, my least favorite story was the one you said that was the most read.

Reader: Every elected official in the county reads MPW [editor: not quite]... and cares what is said about them in the blog. Politicos check it daily (at least) to find out what’s going on ... or to find out how it’s being covered. Mainstream media sources use it as a source, not always with attribution. As MPW’s primary blogger, Adam Pagnucco has solidified it into the state’s leading political blog. One recent indication of its influence: Saqib Ali chose MPW as the engine to launch his recent attack against Nancy King, recognizing the unique ability of MPW to further his agenda.

Reader: Makes and breaks political fortunes. Beware the pol who crosses him. The Gazette and Post are so 90s.

Reader: Has seen a startling rise as a key opinion maker in the County. Many think he is becoming more influential than the Washington Post in political circles, especially as the big paper crumbles. His missives are lucid, nimble and indispensable.

Reader: Because everyone on these lists reads him. One of the few people smart enough to know how to cite real authority but also knows that the numbers were probably juked to begin with.

Reader: This is not done to butter you up ‘cause we have our differences on some issues but you have worked hard to deserve a spot.

Reader: Don’t get a swelled head, nor is this a transparent ass-kissing move. You happen to actually be influential given that many decision-makers consult your blog regularly.

Reader: The political landscape in Montgomery County will never be the same since Maryland Politics Watch partnered with Adam Pagnucco. He is smart, brash, well-informed, has a sense of humor and oh by the way... his blog can make or break a political career. The first thing I do every morning is to check the blog to read what he is reporting. I know that I’m not the only one. There is a new sheriff in town!

Reader: Your posts are must reads around the state. MPW is now featured every day on the Post.com. The Sun now has a reporter who appears to do little more than cover your blog posts – and respond to them. As the Post and Gazette contract and limit local coverage to reporters/editorialists fresh out of distant colleges, Adam will become more powerful at setting the press agenda. He could take this enterprise private and make a good living from the comfort of Forest Estates.

Andres Pagnucco (blogger’s son): Where’s my Daddy??

2. Royce Hanson, M-NCPPC Chairman
31 Votes

Reader: This guy makes the decisions that average voters really care about.

Reader: Especially this year with so many master plans and a new growth policy, Hanson and the planning board have a huge impact on development itself and the sometimes nasty politics surrounding it.

Reader: By determining which projects move forward and when, Royce helps shape our skyline and layout. He’s one of the less visible (and less accountable?) powers in Montgomery County.

Reader: Royce Hanson is currently pushing through growth policy changes and the adoption of a CR zone that will have more radical effects on Montgomery than anything done by the County Council this term.

Reader: In a community where land use battles make an MMA match look like a Precious Moments tea party, Royce commands the respect of all sides.

Reader: Representing the various land use/development communities: Three master plans in the works, plus the annual growth policy. Need I say more?

Reader: The clear leader of the Planning Board and staff. He calls the shots and directs the show.

Reader: He’s gotten some good results out of an agency that has fewer people to do more work. Master and Sector Plans are getting produced. He butts heads with County Council Members, but that is healthy.

Reader: If there is one issue that never goes away in Montgomery County politics, it is development. That’s why the Chair of the Planning Board is one of the most influential people in the County. What Montgomery County looks like in 30 years will be due in no small part to the work of Royce Hanson, the Planning Board and the planning staff. But more importantly, these land use decisions have a huge impact on politics, especially for County offices. Many an officeholder can trace their victory (or defeat) to issues related to projects that went through Hanson’s hands.

Reader: His role on the planning board with the added perspective of a second chance decades later gives him huge say over the future of our county. His new vision, carefully crafted in consultation with Glenn Orlin, will guide our county for the next 20 years no matter who is elected in 2010. However, will lessons learned over the past 40 years in our county serve us well in plotting the next 40 years? Or, has this economic downturn truly resulted in a reset in our thinking which could open the door to new thinking beyond Hanson, Orlin, and Rollin Stanley? It must drive a person like Marc Elrich crazy to have tried for multiple elections to gain a seat on the County Council only to have his ability to shape policy constrained by nameless, powerful bureaucrats like Orlin and Hansen. It should be a lesson to all of the multitudes looking for an At-Large seat.

Adam: Living legend, planning pioneer. Fabled creator of the Ag Reserve. Laid out the basic functions and processes of the Planning Board more than thirty years ago that are still used today. Was the Democratic nominee for Congress in 1964 and 1966, a time when many of today’s elected officials were sucking pacifiers.

1. Jerry Weast, MCPS Superintendent
32 Votes

Reader: Longest serving superintendent in MoCo – no further explanation needed.

Reader: Oversees half the County’s budget. He does it with focus, determination, statistics... and charm, which is an effective combination.

Reader: The public schools are the core of the economy. Jerry Weast is the core of the public schools. He’d make a damned good candidate, too, if he ever decided to run for office.

Reader: Influence has waned significantly, but controls half of the county’s budget and can still dance circles around his board.

Reader: He’s an incredibly powerful school superintendent, plays smart politics which makes him even more influential. He’s much less influential then he was 5 years ago, before first Ervin and then Navarro, Docca, Brandman, Barclay etc. joined and took over the school board, and when Valerie replaced Subin as Council Ed Chair. He controls the largest chunk of the county’s budget, so he’s #1 on the list. He has the best PR operation in the county, probably to the detriment of our county’s students.

Reader: Whether you like him or not, he has moved MCPS to being one of the top school districts in the country.

Reader: Is there another leader in the county whose exploits have been studied by Harvard? He is smart, savvy, and strategic. He controls the largest public enterprise run at the local or state level in our county. A bad word from him could sink many a politician with the Post editorial board who seem to eat out of his hands.

Reader: Won’t be here much longer, but has wielded tremendous power during his tenure and gets great results in the school system. People may not like how political he is, but it has certainly been beneficial to the students of Montgomery County.

Reader: It is a testament to the value placed on public education in Montgomery County that Jerry Weast can be at the same time so polarizing and also be so firmly planted in his post. He does have the good fortune to run a school system in a wealthy, well-educated jurisdiction (it is hard to fail when you have such quality material to work with). Despite his successes, at this point the controversies are more remembered, and many would agree that it is time for him to go.

Adam: Brilliant bully still rules the schools. Will go down as a Hall of Fame power broker. He will only be fully appreciated after his successor comes in and gets bulldozed. Mark my words – the last thing the politicians want is to create another all-powerful Superintendent who regularly upstages them like Jerry Weast.

Well, those are our results for 2009. We’ll give the spies a little time to react, so enjoy the abuse they heap upon us next week!

Read More...

Friday, February 06, 2009

Al Carr Wants You to Know How Your Schools Are Spending Your Money

Last year, the General Assembly unanimously passed a bill that created a searchable online database of vendor payments by state agencies exceeding $25,000. Montgomery County Council Members Phil Andrews and Roger Berliner have introduced a bill that would create a comparable county database. The problem is that neither law would cover Maryland’s public school districts. Delegate Al Carr (D-18) has introduced a local bill requiring the Montgomery County Public Schools (MCPS) to establish its own online database for payments over $10,000. Sounds like a good idea, right?

Not if you’re Superintendent Jerry Weast!

At the January 13 meeting of the Montgomery County Board of Education, school officials listed several objections to Delegate Carr’s bill, including its sole application to MCPS, its lower payment threshold and its $50,000-60,000 cost. Dr. Weast offered these remarks to the Board after a discussion about possible state funding:

I’m very interested in that because here it is a fact that we didn’t get funding and it is a fact that we are losing construction funding and it is a fact that the state has got enormous financial problems. So while there are a lot of wonderful things, one has to do a return on investment and a cost-benefit ratio. What this will do is it causes you ongoing expense and labor cost to maintain, which means that takes away from another area because your budget isn’t going up that much. So I think it’s incumbent upon us to ask – because they just turn to us and say, “take it out of your Bridge to Excellence” or “take it out of your…”

You know, I mean, I try to be very transparent with you about where your money’s at, where it’s going and what it’s tied up with and how it drives our education and construction programs. So I would be very interested to know… It’s important, I’m sure for Mr. Carr to get a bill passed, you know. It’s very early in his legislative career and it must be important to one of his constituents. But who will this benefit? And what level of benefit and who will pay for it are issues I think you have to… We’re going to have to take a more definitive stance than we ever had before because we’ve got less money than we’ve ever had before.
The Board approved a resolution to support Delegate Carr’s bill contingent on receiving state funding for the database’s cost and setting the payment threshold at $25,000. But that was not good enough for Dr. Weast, who went on:

I assume on the last one that you will oppose if the money is not there? Because I’ve seen these bills get through without…

Board Member Chris Barclay: I think given what we raised earlier when we dealt with our legislative position generally that we would oppose anything that’s an unfunded mandate. So thank you for saying that because we do need to be clear the issue here is if we are faced with an unfunded mandate I believe that we have an obligation to oppose it.

Board President Shirley Brandman: I think we’re trying to balance a recognition that it’s not that we oppose accountability, it’s not that we oppose transparency, it’s that we could not do this…

Dr. Weast: I understand, but I, you know… look… you just listened to Highland, you listened to all the efforts we put forth, we’ve cut twenty million… There becomes a law of diminished… I have to advise you as your leader, while it is nice to be kind to everybody, I think kindness is always important, when you get it down to it’s only on us and it’s a much more stringent level than anyplace else, it will cost you more employee time and I haven’t heard any of the benefits that you’re going to reap from this, you know, other than being helpful to somebody that wants to get a bill through.

So oppose unless money is attached sends a completely different signal than support unless money is attached because money is not going to be attached to this. He is not going to get state dollars. I’m not aware of any… I mean, let’s be realistic. If you think they’re going to give a junior Delegate from our county a funding stream for a bill for a particular county… I’ve yet to see that occur. But they will give that Delegate support for a bill so that Delegate gets the bill through but you won’t get the funding stream.
“Your leader!” Now that’s classic Jerry Weast! And you’ve gotta love the fact that no one on the Board corrected him.

Dr. Weast has a good question about how to pay for the database. After all, in a $2 billion+ school budget, it is impossible to find $50,000-60,000. So here are two suggestions:

1. Perhaps citizen activists using the new database could spot questionable practices by the likes of former administrator John Q. Porter, thereby saving the district oodles of money.

2. Or maybe MCPS could crack down on sloppy uses of system credit cards.

But Dr. Weast asks another good question: who benefits from all of this? How about we the taxpayers?

Read More...

Wednesday, December 31, 2008

State Error Shorts MoCo Schools $20-25 Million (Updated)

In a shocking memo only now making the rounds of Montgomery County’s political and educational communities, Superintendent of Schools Jerry Weast reveals that a mistake in state budget formulas resulted in aid underpayment to the county’s schools of $20-25 million in this current budget year. The result of this underpayment contributed to spending reductions this year and may help strain employee benefits next year.

In Maryland, state aid to public schools is driven by a wealth formula. “Wealthier” school districts receive less aid per pupil than “poorer” school districts. One component of this wealth formula is real property value as calculated by the State Department of Assessments and Taxation (SDAT). Districts with higher average real property values receive less money than those with lower values. (To view this year’s distribution of school aid, see page 17 of this document.)

In FY 2009, state aid for MCPS was actually cut because Montgomery County’s wealth level allegedly increased in comparison to other counties. At the time he learned of the cut, Dr. Weast claims he complained of an error in the calculations to the County Executive, County Council and state delegation. In a memo to the Board of Education released yesterday, Dr. Weast says he has been proven correct. SDAT now admits that it overestimated the value of real property in Montgomery County by $15.8 billion because it double-counted new homes. The result is that Montgomery lost $20-25 million in state aid due from the wealth formula. That money was instead paid out to other school districts in the state.

Dr. Weast also goes into great detail about the consequences of cuts in further state aid. If Montgomery County loses funding under the state’s Geographic Cost of Education Index (GCEI), a formula that routes money to districts with higher costs of education, and receives less aid under aspects of the state’s wealth formula, MCPS may not be able to fully fund its pension and health obligations. This endangers employee benefits after the school employees gave up $89 million of cost-of-living adjustments.

But that lies in the future. The present problem is the county’s loss of $20-25 million in mandated state aid in the current fiscal year (FY 2009), money that has already been allocated to other school districts in Maryland. That creates a gigantic political problem with multiple dimensions:

1. Who knew and what did they do about it?
In his memo, Dr. Weast said he suspected a shortfall all along and complained about it to the County Executive, County Council and state delegation. Did anyone investigate his complaint? If so, what did they learn? And when did they learn it? Dr. Weast believes the error was discovered as early as August 2008. Was it known earlier? And did anyone at the state level take steps to correct it?

2. Wasted conflict at the County Council
As we covered extensively on this blog, the County Council agonized over the FY 2009 budget. As late as the last days of discussion, County Council Members Phil Andrews, Duchy Trachtenberg and Roger Berliner were proposing furloughs of county employees that would save $20.5 million. The final budget agreement reduced the County Executive’s proposed tax hike by $20 million and called for $8 million in savings by both MCPS and the rest of the government. If the state aid had been calculated properly, these conflicts could have been avoided.

3. Distrust of the Governor
For some time now, Montgomery County’s leaders have felt growing distrust of Governor O’Malley. His unrepentant shorting of school construction money is one reason. MDOT’s significant cuts to both the Purple Line and the Corridor Cities Transitway while protecting funding for Baltimore’s Red Line is another reason. (The school construction money and transit funding were among the promises made by the administration to Montgomery’s delegation in return for their votes on the special session’s tax and slots bills.) This issue will deepen and exacerbate that distrust.

4. Who will act to recover the money?
At present, our informants are unaware of any state plans to pay back the $20-25 million Montgomery is owed in this fiscal year. Will the County Executive, the state delegation or anyone else call the administration to the mat on this one? If not, then what are the consequences to the state of shorting Montgomery County?

Readers, we now have the first burning political issue of 2009.

Update: The Washington Post quotes Governor O'Malley as saying that MCPS will get the $24 million it is owed and that the other districts can keep their overpayment. But Dr. Weast is now accusing the state of a "cover-up" going back several months. My sources say that County Executive Leggett spoke to the Governor on New Year's Eve and the understanding they reached was to "sit down soon to work this out."

Following is the complete text of Dr. Weast’s memo to the Board of Education.

*****

Office of the Superintendent of Schools
Montgomery County Public Schools
Rockville, Maryland
December 30, 2008

Memorandum

To: Members of the Board of Education
From: Jerry D. Weast, Superintendent of Schools
Subject: FY 2010 Operating Budget: State Aid

On December 11, 2008, I transmitted my Recommended FY 2010 Operating Budget to the Board of Education. In prior years, when I sent me budget to the Board, I had the preliminary state aid estimates from the Maryland State Department of Education (MSDE). However, I did not receive the preliminary estimates for FY 2010 state aid for public schools until December 22, 2008.

On December 26, 2008, I informed you about these preliminary FY 2010 estimates for state aid. The revenue estimates include an increase in state aid for Montgomery County Public Schools (MCPS) of $71.1 million (17.8 percent) to $470.4 million. This is $50.3 million higher than the estimates included in my FY 2010 Recommended Operating Budget. These preliminary FY 2010 state aid estimates are subject to change in the Governor’s FY 2010 recommended budget due in January 2009. In addition, any change in state funding formulas made by the General Assembly during the 2009 legislative session will be reflected in the final FY 2010 state aid allocations next April. I expect changes in the revenue from the state by the time the General Assembly approves the budget.

The main reason for this significant increase in state aid is an increase of $57.4 million in basic Foundation aid primarily as a result of an apparent decrease in the relative wealth of Montgomery County compared to other counties in Maryland. Because state aid is wealth equalized, the share of state aid received by Montgomery County is higher than last year. According to the preliminary calculations, Montgomery County would receive $69 million of the $91 million of increased mandated state aid. These figures are a complete reversal from last year’s change in real property wealth, which resulted in MCPS losing state aid for FY 2009. However, the State Department of Assessments and Taxation now recognizes that the real property wealth calculations for Montgomery County were mistaken for FY 2009 by approximately $15.8 billion, possibly because of a double count of new homes. Last year, I informed the Board of Education I felt there had to be an error in the wealth calculation. We also informed the County Executive, County Council and our delegation of a possible error. However, no corrections were made last year. I have learned that the error was discovered as early as August 2008. Preliminary estimates are that we have lost between $20 million and $25 million of mandated state aid this year. The increase in state aid estimated for FY 2010 does not correct the error made last year but appears greater than it should be because of the FY 2009 error.

The FY 2010 state aid for Montgomery County includes $31 million for full funding of the Geographic Cost of Education Index (GCEI) as required by current law. However, GCEI funding is not mandated in the Governor’s budget. As you know, there is discussion that the Governor plans the current year’s allocation of GCEI funding by half, or $9 million. If the GCEI is not funded for FY 2010, MCPS would still receive an increase of $40.1 million over the FY 2009 approved budget instead of $71.1 million. This is only $19.4 million more than the $420 million estimated for state aid in my FY 2010 Recommended Operating Budget. The total of $420 million is an increase of $20.7 million over the FY 2009 state total.

Assuming this increase in state aid of $40.1 million, the operating budget request will have to be increased above the amount of my recommended budget by $19.4 million. The County Council cannot use this additional state aid to reduce the county’s contribution to MCPS because it would be in default of the state Maintenance of Effort requirement. Increased enrollment in FY 2009 requires the county to increase the local contribution to MCPS by $16.2 million. My recommended operating budget assumes that this increase in county contribution will come entirely from savings generated by MCPS this year rather than from new county tax revenues.

Therefore, as a result of these new preliminary state aid estimates, I am amending my recommended budget submitted to you on December 11, 2008. Because of the uncertainty of these additional state funds and the fact that we cannot count on this funding being available in April 2009, we cannot change the budget we have in place. The changes I am making will not affect the $35 million of reductions in the FY 2010 operating budget, the elimination of cost of living adjustments for our employees, or the $20 million in savings that will be generated from the freeze in the current year. My priority is to protect our employees as much as possible from reductions in future years to benefit programs. This can be done by using the additional state funds for expenditures in benefit programs that will require significant budget increases in FY 2011. As you know, my budget did not permit inclusion of $12.3 million scheduled for FY 2010 for the Retiree Health Trust Fund (OPEB). The contribution to OPEB could increase by as much as $24 million in FY 2011. If these additional state funds are available in FY 2010, we should try to adhere to the current eight-year phase-in of OPEB funding and add the $12.3 million to the budget.

Additionally, it is important to add resources to the Employee Benefit Plan (EPB) internal services fund to have sufficient reserves to absorb unanticipated increased costs for health care coverage for active and retired employees. As a result of decisions made last spring to fund the FY 2009 Operating Budget, the trust fund balance of almost $21 million at the end of FY 2008 will be reduced by as much as $10 million this year to fund EPB costs. In addition, my recommended budget for FY 2010 assumes we will need to reduce this fund balance even further. In order to avoid the possibility of a shortfall in the EPB fund that would need to be replenished in FY 2011 and to maintain an appropriate balance in the trust fund, I will recommend that an additional $7.1 million be approved for the fund.

Finally, if additional state aid beyond the $19.4 million is available next spring, I would recommend placing these funds in the MCPS Employees’ Retirement and Pension Systems plan. We anticipate significantly higher retirement payments in FY 2011 because market returns in FY 2009 will be far below actuarial expectations. This would require significant increases in employer contributions in FY 2011 to maintain the funded status of the program. Therefore, it would be prudent to make additional allocations into the plan if there is additional state aid next spring.

Because of the seriousness of the economic situation in the county, the state, and the nation, it is doubtful that MCPS will receive the additional $71 million of state aid. If the only change that is made is the elimination of the GCEI and we receive an additional $40.1 million in state aid, we should attempt to take pressure off of the FY 2011 budget that will result from significant increases for the health and retirement plans. I believe this is the more prudent action the Board can take. If we do not receive the additional $19.4 million above my preliminary projections for state aid, then we would need to eliminate these increases for OPEB and the contributions to the EPB trust fund in the spring.

I still am concerned about the error that was made last year which resulted in an underpayment to MCPS and an overpayment in a similar amount to the other school systems in the state. We should work with the County Executive and our delegation to pursue this with the Governor.

I will continue to keep you informed of further developments on this issue. If you have any questions, please call Mr. Larry A. Bowers, chief operating officer, at 301-279-3626 or Dr. Marshall Spatz, director, Department of Management, Budget, and Planning at 301-279-3547.

JDW:sz

Copy to:
Executive Staff
Ms. Cullison [MCEA]
Ms. Cuttitta [SEIU Local 500]
Dr. Newman [MCAASP]

Read More...

Tuesday, November 18, 2008

The Defining Crisis of Weast's Era: Teachers, Salaries, and Workload

By Eric Luedtke.

For those of you on a time crunch, here’s the summary: Teachers are essential to student success. Teachers are probably losing most if not all of their scheduled cost of living adjustment. This could lead to the loss of good teachers in the school system. To offset the loss of the COLA, the school system needs to start being serious about streamlining the work of teachers so they can spend their time serving students rather than in makework or unnecessary tasks.

Crises are defining moments for leaders in the public sphere. Lincoln wouldn't have been Lincoln without the Civil War, Washington would have remained a little known veteran of the French and Indian War if no shots had been fired on Lexington Green, and FDR's greatness was brought to light in his response to the dual crises of the Great Depression and World War Two. Today's history lesson ends there, so don't run off yet, because there is a point to this in the here and now.

There's a local application of the crisis rule that we're beginning to see play out in our own community, in the schools whose success has been so central to Montgomery County's prosperity over the last few decades. For nearly a decade, MCPS has been in what can only be called the Weast Era. It's been an era of relatively rapid changes and reforms, an era where the system refocused itself around priorities like closing the achievement gap, doing a better job addressing the needs of students with special needs and English language learners, and crafting an elite instructional workforce to help meet those goals. It’s been a very successful era, but now, for the first time in more than a decade, forces outside our local control are threatening that success. How Dr. Weast, the Board of Education, and the County Council respond will quite possibly define their careers as public servants.

The Weast Era has coincided with a long period of economic prosperity, with the exception of the slowdown after 9/11. Consistent and sustainable funding is essential to the success of a school system, so these have been good years for MCPS. When the money is easy to come by, it's relatively easy to drive reform in schools. The dollars Dr. Weast secured through a decade of prosperity have paid for the full implementation of all-day kindergarten, major class size reductions in elementary schools, and a variety of reforms-in-progress in middle and high schools. He has also, in conjunction with the board of education and the unions, developed a salary and benefit package aimed at making sure the best educators work in Montgomery County. This is partially a competitive necessity - we're surrounded by other high-paying jurisdictions - and partially a way to offset falling morale due to increasing workload.

Weast himself acknowledges that he and the leadership of the school system ask a lot of their employees, and that the impressive salary increases over the last few years are designed to offset that. As his reforms have been put in place, the professionals who implement them have been asked to work harder and harder every year. We've learned new ways of using data to drive decision making at the classroom, school, and system level. We've mastered new technology in the classroom and system-wide. We've found new methods for communicating with parents. We've retooled the school system to allow students with special needs more access to mainstream settings. But one thing has not changed - the amount of time we have to get all of this done. The school day and work day are unchanged from when I was a student in MCPS, under Dr. Weast’s predecessor.

There has been some grumbling, to be sure, though the vast majority of staff have accepted the reforms and come to value many of the changes. But grumbling was never the concern. The concern has always been the effect of this on staff retention. To provide a good education, we need good teachers. If increased workload started driving good teachers out of the system, the reforms would be useless. So the school system leadership under Weast made a calculation – pay high salaries to teachers to keep them in the classroom. It’s helped to keep good teachers in the classroom through ten years of aggressive, sometimes disruptive reforms.

But large salary increases no longer seem to be a possibility. The school system unions have gone back to the bargaining table in the hope of trying to solve MCPS’ budget problems before they get out of hand. This will almost certainly entail a partial or full loss of the 5% cost of living adjustment scheduled for the next school year. That’s money that was already promised to teachers that they now won’t get.

This loss will be a blow to morale. It will start some teachers looking for jobs in other places, like in the federal government where many employees are still getting a 5% COLA. Unless he wants to watch his reforms unravel around his ears, Dr. Weast is going to have to do something about that.

The only solution is to take a serious look at workload. There isn’t money for improvements in salaries or benefits. And there isn’t money for the sort of big-picture workload reductions many teachers would like to see, like smaller class sizes. But there are low or no cost steps the system could take that will have profound effect on the workload of teachers, while not in any way hurting the education of students. In fact, done right, streamlining the work of our educators may make them better able to serve students.

Step one is making attention to workload as central a part of the system’s operation as attention to money. Any time required by a new initiative needs to be offset by time or workload reductions in some other area. And any central office bureaucrats whose actions affect the work of direct service providers need to take a serious look at how their actions may impact workload.

Beyond that commitment, low or no-cost impact on workload will only come through a series of small, incremental improvements. E-mail has rendered many whole-staff meetings obsolete, so those can be reduced. Advances in file-sharing networks would make it possible for the school system to allow teachers to share lessons and materials electronically, if they would only make such a space available and drop the condescending insistence that every lesson a teacher writes needs to be vetted by central office staff. There needs to be a serious analysis of paperwork to eliminate those things which are little more than busywork for frontline educators whose time is better spent serving children. And the system needs to stop doing an end run around contract by allowing some schools on block schedules to force teachers to teach 6 classes instead of five – it only stresses teachers and reduces their ability to serve students. If the system is really committed to eight-period blocks, they need to pay the marginally more expensive cost of 5/8 schedules and give teachers the time to plan collaboratively and participate in teacher-driven professional development.

This recession will be Dr. Weast’s defining test as a leader in MCPS. On the one hand, there is the possibility that loss of salaries will lead to loss of good teachers and the system will start to slide backwards. On the other, there is the possibility that by changing tactics, the system will be able to continue to attract and retain exceptional educators, and maintain its path down the road to success for all students. For the sake of Montgomery County’s children, I hope that Dr. Weast and the other leaders of the school system will pass the test.

Eric Luedtke is a teacher at A. Mario Loiederman Middle School and a member of the board of the Montgomery County Education Association.

Read More...